1. "If" and "Whether" Noun Clauses
Noun clauses starting with if or whether are used to report yes/no questions indirectly or to express uncertainty or a choice between two possibilities.
Direct Question: Is the train on time?
* Noun Clause: I wonder if the train is on time.
* Noun Clause: I wonder whether the train is on time.
Notice that the word order in the noun clause is a statement (the train is), not a question (is the train).
2. Functions in a Sentence
These clauses can perform several noun-like jobs in a sentence.
a) Subject of the Sentence
The clause acts as the subject of the main verb.
* Whether she will come is the main question.
* If he can finish the project on time remains to be seen.
(Note: Using 'whether' as a subject is much more common and often considered more formal and correct than 'if'.)
b) Direct Object of a Verb
The clause receives the action of the verb. This is the most common function.
* She asked if I knew the way.
* I don't know whether I should tell him.
* Let me know if you need anything.
c) Object of a Preposition
The clause follows a preposition (like about, on, of).
* We had a discussion about whether we should expand the business.
* His decision depends on whether he gets the loan.
(Important Rule: Only 'whether' can be used after a preposition. Using 'if' is grammatically incorrect.)
* Incorrect: We talked about ~~if we should go~~.
* Correct: We talked about whether we should go.
d) Subject Complement
The clause follows a linking verb (like is, was, seems) and renames or describes the subject.
* The problem is whether we have enough money for the trip.
* The key question remains if the defendant is truly guilty.
(Note: 'Whether' is strongly preferred in this position for clarity and formality.)
3. The Big Question: "If" vs. "Whether"
While they are often interchangeable (especially as direct objects), there are clear rules and stylistic preferences for choosing between them. "Whether" is the more versatile and safer choice.
Use whether (and not if):
* After a Preposition:
* There is some doubt about whether the report is accurate.
* Before an Infinitive (to + verb):
* She can't decide whether to stay or to go. (You cannot say "if to stay")
* When the clause is the Subject of the sentence:
* Whether you succeed or not is up to you. (Using if here is awkward and rare).
* To give a clear choice between two options, especially with "or not":
* I don't care whether you like the music or not.
* Let me know whether or not you are attending.
When can you use if?
You can almost always use if when the noun clause is the direct object of a verb and is expressing a simple, indirect yes/no question, especially in informal speech.
* He asked if I was feeling okay. (Here, whether would also be correct).
* I wonder if it's going to rain. (Here, whether would also be correct).
A Note on Ambiguity: Sometimes, if can be ambiguous.
* "Please tell me if she calls."
* Meaning 1 (Noun Clause): Please tell me the answer to the question, "Will she call?"
* Meaning 2 (Adverbial/Conditional Clause): You should only tell me in the event that she calls.
Using whether removes this ambiguity:
* "Please tell me whether she calls." (This can only have Meaning 1).
Summary Table
| Situation | Whether | If | Example |
| As a Direct Object | Yes (more formal) | Yes (more common/informal) | I wonder whether/if he's coming. |
| As the Subject | Preferred | Awkward/Rare | Whether he agrees is not important. |
| After a Preposition | Correct | Incorrect | We are concerned about whether it is safe. |
| Before an Infinitive | Correct | Incorrect | He must decide whether to invest. |
| With "or not" | Clear & Preferred | Less Common | I'm going whether or not you join me. |
Rule of Thumb: When in doubt, use whether. It is correct in all the places if is used for noun clauses, but the reverse is not true.
Posts
